Career Planning

Crafting The Self Journal Experience

Crafting The Self Journal Experience

A sneak peek into the journey we travelled when designing the customer experience for the Self Journal. From the packaging design, to the mailing box to everything in between.

When developing BestSelf from a Kickstarter-funded company into a business and e-commerce store, Allen, myself and the BestSelf team were very conscious about crafting every piece of the customer experience. From the design of the store to the product packaging to the mailing box it was delivered in.

How could we make every step of the journey a pleasurable experience?

Don’t underestimate how much these things matter. Think of a company that has an excellent customer experience.


Nothing is too small to be beautiful. Every inch of the packaging is thoughtfully crafted enough that many of us even save the box because it seems a shame to throw out.

(Essentially since I’m living in New York City I pay a portion of rent for my Macbook Pro box.)

When designing the Self Journal, our flagship product, we knew we wanted to create a similar experience to Apple from the moment our product arrived at a customers door to actually opening the package.

Some questions we asked:

- How can we build anticipation before the Self Journal box is opened?
- How do we create an experience to remember?
- Can we tell a story through the packaging?

Why Packaging Was So Important:

Over the past several years I’ve dealt with the postal service enough through my another e-commerce venture to know that sending books, or in this case, beautiful journals in a package without external protection would only end in disaster.

Additionally, with the 13 Week dry-erase wall calendar we included with each Self journal it seemed the only answer was a box. While the box was a practical answer for these problems, it could also serve a greater purpose - it was an opportunity to create an experience and tell a story.

The Box Design

Creating Packaging with Purpose

Our mission was to design a beautiful box that people would keep, but we didn’t want it stored in the back of a closet somewhere gathering dust, it should still serve a purpose.The Self Journal chronicles your goals and serves as a physical representation of your achievements. These goals should be celebrated and put on display which is why we designed the box the way we did.

On each side of the box is a visual representation of the book that sits within. It was minimalist yet tells you what you need to know. Some rough original sketches:

Visual representation of the book

We used this water image from Unsplash by Kate Chikina to serve as the base of the book texture on each side of the box. This water theme distills a sense of focused calm.

The box water theme

The Design:

Box design

By using a spot-gloss coating on the side of the box it could be used to label the journal box for your own records, which becomes a way to chronicle your goals.

the Self Journal box

The Final Product:

Final product Self Journal box

The Box Outside The Box

The beautiful Self Journal box would need to be sent within another box to avoid damage. We had a two options;

- a standard box (boring)
- designing custom boxes with our branding on the outside (fun!)

We liked the idea of designing a custom box, however, due to the economies of scale, this didn’t seem very sensible. With a few different product offerings, we’d be paying for high costs low minimums for different sizes of boxes.

The box outside the box

What if someone purchased a bulk order that needed a larger box? Essentially this is a valued customer, yet we would need to use a regular box, and so they would not get the same experience as someone who bought less.

Every customer should receive the same care, consideration, and buying experience - without breaking the bank. Then I got an Amazon package through the mail and had my a-ha moment.

Amazon package

Custom kraft packing tape that could be taped on any shape of any box, mailing tube etc.

We got to work, sourced a supplier close to our fulfillment center in Minnesota and got a template. The template was 14“ x 3” wide so the key was creating a design that looked good in a repeating pattern.

While our logo made sense for branding purposes, I wanted to make it more than just a promotional design. Much like our other design elements, it could and should serve a dual and greater purpose. Could we somehow positively affect someone who’s not even the intended recipient?

That’s where the idea for quotes on the packing tape came from:

Packing tape with quotes

The End result:

Final results of box

Hand-Lettered by a founder

Getting postcards or promotional material inside a product case isn’t anything new, we knew this. However, we wanted to create something with high touch that showed how grateful and thankful we were to our supporters and customers. A design element that couldn't be re-created easily by just anyone.

I had been playing around with some hand letting for a while and decided to see what I could come up with for Best Self so in the weeks after the Kickstarter ended I started sketching and brainstorming ideas.

The Pencil Sketch & Inked Letters;

The pencil sketch & inked letters

After digitizing the original sketch and cleaning it up, this was the final result:

Final results after digitizing


The last piece was working on a composition and how everything fit together. While designing the interior insert to go within the box I created some small sketches to show the manufacturer how each journal should be placed within the box with the calendar and the insert.

How each journal should be placed within the box with the calendar and the insert
Sef Journal
The yellow bookmark serving with a secondary function so as to easily lift the book from the box.

The Final Product:

The final product

Customer Experience:

We knew we were onto something when within minutes of people receiving the product we were getting tweets, Instagrams and emails from Kickstarter backers and pre-order supporters:

Customer experience

Reading next

What Stephen Curry Can Teach Us About Creating Successful Habits
How to Set Goals & Actually Reach Them

Leave a comment

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.